UK Value Investor

For defensive value investors

Investment Newsletter Subscriber Login
  • Blog
    • FTSE share reviews
    • UK market valuations
    • Investment srategy
    • Case studies
    • Portfolio updates
    • Magazine articles
  • Book
  • Portfolio
  • About
  • Contact

Billington Holdings – One last tangible asset play

March 18, 2011 By John Kingham

“Billington Holdings Plc is a UK based group of companies providing structural steel and safety solution services to the UK market.  Structural Steel comprises Billington Structures, the award-winning and nationally recognised steelwork contractor.  Easi-Edge is a leading provider of Safety Solutions to the construction industry.”
(billington-holdings.plc.uk)
I bought Billington back in November at 85 pence but haven’t got round to analysing in writing yet, so I thought I’d nail this one before moving on to my recent turnaround purchases. 

I liked this company because of its strong balance sheet, low price to book and price to earnings ratios, but in this review I’ll look at it from a defensive Ben Graham view, with some Buffett-like projections thrown in.
Starting with the company as at now:
  1. Is the company of substantial size?
Large companies can be more consistent in their results and more robust in the face of hardship, but not always.  Billington is an AIM listed micro-cap (~£12M), so it is not large in any sense.
  1. Do they have low levels of debt?
Yes, they have net cash.
  1. Are they currently generating a profit, free cash and a dividend?
Profit, free cash and dividends are all good signs of a healthy company.  For Billington the answer is yes, no and no.  Free cash does seem to be a slight problem with Billington, with three in eleven years having no free cash and in fact negative cash flows in total.  This may be a consequence of heavy capital expenditure requirements.
Looking back into the company’s past:
  1. Have earnings per share, turnover, book value and the dividend all increased in the last decade?
Increasing earnings, at least in line with inflation over the long term, is a minimum requirement for a Ben Graham defensive company.  For Billington it seems that the answer is sadly no.  EPS has been quite volatile with positive and negative results, but no clear upward trend.  Turnover is down by about 50%, book value per share is slightly lower and dividends have only been paid in seven of eleven years with the most recent one cut drastically.
  1. Have profits, dividends and free cash been positive for at least nine of the last ten years?
Again no; dividends, free cash and earnings have all been negative in multiple years.
  1. Is the return on equity consistently in double digits?
It is usually in double digits in the 20-40% range, but it has been negative and in single digits in a few years.
  1. Is return on capital consistently high?
Again it’s quite lumpy.  The good times were 2004-2008, which is what you’d expect for a company in the building business.
  1. Has the company produced a good return on reinvested earnings?
Since 1999 Billington has retained 64.35p per share of its basic earnings.  In that time there has been no clear increase in EPS or in the book value of the company, so it could be argued that no real return has been produced from those retained earnings, which is not brilliant.
  1. What is the total expected return over five and ten years if the shares traded at their historic average PE?
Billington isn’t really suitable to long term projections as its earnings are so variable.  However, the average earnings per share over the last decade are 19 pence and at the average price earnings ratio of 6.1 that gives a price of 116 pence, which isn’t far above where we are now. 
Taking it a step further, if I say next year their earnings normalise from the current 8p back to 19p (which isn’t hard to believe since the 2009 earnings were 33p) and then grow at the historic average of 6% (although that 6% isn’t smooth by any means as the earnings jump all over the place), then the earnings might be 25p in five years, giving a share price of 155p, which plus dividends paid out at the historic average cover of 3.2 gives a total return of 124%.  Do the same math over 10 years and you get 240%.  A 100% return in 5 years is about 15% annualised which is right on target.
  1. How likely is it that the earnings projections are in the right ballpark?  Or, does the company have a durable competitive advantage?
Billington does not have a durable competitive advantage so the projections are no more than a guess that at some point in the next few years the earnings will be about average as will the price to earnings ratio.
This company scores pretty badly on this kind of analysis, which is fair enough given that I bought it under different criteria; but I’m getting interested in this kind of work, of looking for good companies rather than just cheap ones, so I need the practice.  In fact I really need the practice when you see some of the other things I’ve bought lately.
For Billington my conclusion is that it’s a hold, since I think it’s a fair bet that the return on an 85p purchase price could be over 100% within 5 years.  Now the trick is to be patient enough to hold it for that long.

Dear fellow investor,

This website was my home on the internet from 2008 to 2021, but I have now moved onwards and upwards to:

UKDividendStocks.com

To read the latest company reviews and other content, please head over to the new site.

Thank you

John Kingham

Comments

  1. John says

    July 7, 2011 at 8:02 am

    You can see where I sold Billington here:

    https://www.ukvalueinvestor.com/2011/05/may-2011.html

After 13 years of writing about UK stocks on this website I have now moved to my new home at:

UKDividendStocks.com

Please head over to the new site.

Thank you

John Kingham

RSS UK Dividend Stocks Blog

  • How to avoid dividend traps with excessive debts
  • Find quality dividend stocks using these profitability ratios
  • Selling Hikma Pharmaceuticals after a 40% share price gain in 7 months
  • How to identify stocks with high-quality dividend growth
  • Secure Trust Bank: Is its dividend secure and trustworthy?
  • How to find quality companies with consistent profits and dividends
  • The pros and cons of savings vs dividends for retirement income
  • Top 40 High-Yield Blue-Chip UK Stocks: Spring 2023
  • UK Housing Market Valuation and Forecast for 2023
  • S&P 500 CAPE Valuation and Forecast for 2023

My Book

  • The Defensive Value Investor
  • "I believe this book is among the best value investing books, if not the best."
    Amazon.com review
  • "Definitely worth a look for any stock-picking private investor"
    Dr Matthew Partridge, MoneyWeek
Disclaimer: This website provides information for educational purposes only. It does not provide financial advice or recommendations to buy or sell any investment. Do your own research or ask a regulated financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Copyright © 2023

UKValueInvestor.com Ltd, 160 Eureka Park, Ashford, Kent, TN25 4AZ


The purpose of this website is to provide information and education to investors. It does not provide financial advice or recommendations to buy or sell specific investments and is therefore not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. If you need financial advice you should consult with a regulated financial adviser.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to use the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Okay Reject Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT