UK Value Investor

For defensive value investors

Investment Newsletter Subscriber Login
  • Blog
    • FTSE share reviews
    • UK market valuations
    • Investment srategy
    • Case studies
    • Portfolio updates
    • Magazine articles
  • Book
  • Portfolio
  • About
  • Contact

How to cope with the surge in profit warnings

November 26, 2015 By John Kingham

This guest post comes from occasional contributor, Rob Davies. Rob manages the Smart Dividend Fund.

Autumn is traditionally the season for profit warnings but this year is bringing a more bountiful crop than usual. According to Ernst & Young there was a 40% increase to 79 in the third quarter. And there have been more since.

Some of these have surprised the market while others have merely confirmed suspicions that not everything is rosy. No one likes to deliver bad news so it is human nature, even for Chief Executives, to delay giving it out for as long as possible.

By the time companies have reached the start of the fourth quarter of the year it will be pretty obvious what the overall result for the year is going to be within a reasonable margin of error. Whatever happens in the fourth quarter it is unlikely to alter the final outcome that much.

Clearly, this year, with its spate of profit warnings, is not going as well as most bosses had hoped. What is surprising is the range of industries that are telling us how tough life is.

Profit warnings left, right and centre

The woes of the oil and mining companies have been well documented and the cause – low commodity prices – is clear to all.

Other industries where problems are not a surprise are luxury goods manufacturers selling into China as more modest levels of growth, and a crackdown on corruption, has made lifer harder there.

Another sector whose problems are apparent to all are supermarkets and indeed retailers generally. Not only have competitors joined the fray with ultra-low pricing on a narrow range of products but the Internet continues to grab a rising share of discretionary spending because of its sheer utility and ease of price comparison.

More surprising have been the words of caution from companies supplying the booming house-building industry where rapid growth is apparently getting harder to sustain.

An overstimulated and exhausted business cycle

It is hard to identify any single factor that unites these businesses except perhaps the fading of the massive financial stimulus that started in 2009 with very low interest rates and Quantitative Easing.

That worked well initially as it acted to use up spare capacity. Eventually though, no matter how cheap money is, if customers don’t spend any more when they come through the shop door, or they see no need to replace a car they only bought three years ago growth will drift back to the long term trend. Which, in the mature economies of the West, is probably around two to three percent.

In order to grow faster than that a company has to either create an entirely new product with a great idea or increase its market share at the expense of others. The latter of course being a zero-sum game as one company’s gain is another one’s loss of market share. In the end both probably suffer from lower margins so it is hard to even preserve profitability.

All we are really seeing is an exercise in managing expectations as we approach the end of an unusually long business cycle. Chief executives tend to have fairly short shelf lives these days as professional managers hop from one company to another as part of their campaign to leapfrog peers in their own company to win promotion. How often have we heard the claim that Mr, Mrs or Ms So and So has a fresh pair of eyes and will tackle the problems differently?

Those that benefited from QE are now finding it harder to maintain the growth that QE delivered as a single-use remedy. Now that has run its course growth must come from more mundane business techniques.

In the end it is all about growing the top-line and attempts to supercharge these by takeovers, increasing debt, incentives or marketing spend usually fail with consequences we can see in fallen corporate titans everywhere.

It’s time to suck it up

Profit warnings are really just a crude way of CEOs saying:

“Life is tough. All that guff I gave you a few years ago about going for growth was just hot air. In reality we are not going to deliver double digit growth in a world where GDP is growing at 2 or 3 percent and inflation is 1% if you are lucky”

As investors we need to man-up and accept that business has cycles and we have been lucky enough to experience a remarkable recovery in the last six years courtesy of central banks and governments.

That has finished; it is over. Get used to it and be prepared for modest returns for the foreseeable future, but with a few holes in the road on the way.

You can try picking stocks to avoid the pitfalls. However, Brinson and his colleagues in Chicago demonstrated decades years ago that 90% of your returns comes from asset allocation. Spending hours attempting to dodge the companies that might fail is simply not worth the time.

So ignore profit warnings. Just buy the whole asset class and accept the business cycle.

John says: Obviously I would disagree with Rob’s last sentiment that stock picking is not worth the time. However, I do agree that there is a noticeable pick-up in the number of profit warnings and dividend cuts. I also pointed out the decline in aggregate UK corporate earnings in this FTSE 100 review. How long this lasts is anybody’s guess, but perhaps Rob is right that current post-crisis business cycle is ending, which may mean another recession is just around the corner. That may not be a bad thing as desperate attempts to avoid a recession usually just store up more trouble for the future, in my opinion.

Dear fellow investor,

This website was my home on the internet from 2008 to 2021, but I have now moved onwards and upwards to:

UKDividendStocks.com

To read the latest company reviews and other content, please head over to the new site.

Thank you

John Kingham

Comments

  1. bargainvalue says

    November 30, 2015 at 10:31 am

    Great article. Many people to often forget, that we have business cycles and it is something we must to live with. Moreover, actions taken by governments and central banks stimulate the economy, but in most cases it is “artificial” growth. You cannot count on miracle, if you just inflate the statistics. I like the fragment about companies, that in order to growth need to create entirly new product. It is the same thinking, that is the base of start-ups; solve the problem, which hasn’t been solved yet or improve 10 times the exsisting product. Politicians to often forget, that the innovations drive the only truth and healthy growth. Nowadays, when we look at GNP we usually see “horizontal” growth; produce more, faster, more efficient the same things. This kind of thinking creat a lot of pathology (e.g. companies deliberately creat goods with shorter life time; the consumer will need to come back faster for the new product). No need to mention, that GNP is a very poor measure of real quality of life or state of environment. In my opinion, the world should more focus on inequalities and how to enable e.g. China and India to growth healthy. People from these countries want the same quality of life like in USA/UE, but right now it is impossible to achieve this without great advancement in technology and economical thinking.

    • John Kingham says

      December 3, 2015 at 1:22 pm

      Thanks. You’re right that business cycles are a fact of live, but personally I would prefer it if government went back to being countercyclical rather than just always trying to push the economy upwards/forwards. Boom and bust is not a good system and it has definitely not been consigned to the history books (regardless of what Gordon Brown thinks/thought).

After 13 years of writing about UK stocks on this website I have now moved to my new home at:

UKDividendStocks.com

Please head over to the new site.

Thank you

John Kingham

RSS UK Dividend Stocks Blog

  • How to avoid dividend traps with excessive debts
  • Find quality dividend stocks using these profitability ratios
  • Selling Hikma Pharmaceuticals after a 40% share price gain in 7 months
  • How to identify stocks with high-quality dividend growth
  • Secure Trust Bank: Is its dividend secure and trustworthy?
  • How to find quality companies with consistent profits and dividends
  • The pros and cons of savings vs dividends for retirement income
  • Top 40 High-Yield Blue-Chip UK Stocks: Spring 2023
  • UK Housing Market Valuation and Forecast for 2023
  • S&P 500 CAPE Valuation and Forecast for 2023

My Book

  • The Defensive Value Investor
  • "I believe this book is among the best value investing books, if not the best."
    Amazon.com review
  • "Definitely worth a look for any stock-picking private investor"
    Dr Matthew Partridge, MoneyWeek
Disclaimer: This website provides information for educational purposes only. It does not provide financial advice or recommendations to buy or sell any investment. Do your own research or ask a regulated financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Copyright © 2023

UKValueInvestor.com Ltd, 160 Eureka Park, Ashford, Kent, TN25 4AZ


The purpose of this website is to provide information and education to investors. It does not provide financial advice or recommendations to buy or sell specific investments and is therefore not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. If you need financial advice you should consult with a regulated financial adviser.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to use the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Okay Reject Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT